Memo mailed to Jaime Shandera listed twelve members of a new organisation, Majestic/MJ-12, tasked with the alien problem
“It also listed a group of twelve members of a new organization tasked with dealing with the "alien problem." The group, called Majestic or "MJ 12,"”
Dark Mission
ch12:70700-70843
Truman Directive directed Bush and Forrestal to set up MJ-12 and report to Truman; Forrestal met Tizard within a week, early October 1947
“within one week of the Truman directive to Bush and James Forrestal to, in fact, set up Majestic 12 and to report directly to him, at the beginning of October 1947, Forrestal then had a meeting with Sir Henry Tizard, who at that time was the chief scientific advisor to the Ministry of Defence.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:13:30.1-00:13:56.4
The directive was leaked around 1980 to two filmmakers, and the material became known as the Majestic 12 documents
“There was a Truman Directive 24th of September 1947 in a document that was leaked in 1980 or so to two filmmakers. And those documents became known as the Majestic 12 documents”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:16:47.6-00:17:01.9
The documents allegedly established MJ-12 as responsible for retrieval of non-human craft
“they established allegedly Majestic 12 as the group responsible for the retrieval of non-human craft.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:17:08.8-00:17:17.1
Provenance of the documents is officially disputed by the FBI and US military
“the provenance of which is still, of course, disputed officially by the FBI and the US military.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:17:02.4-00:17:07.5
Bush and Menzel named as founding members in the Shandera memo
“included both Bush and Menzel as founding members”
Dark Mission
ch12:70848-70890
Menzel's presence used by debunkers as proof of forgery, given his public debunking record
“At first, debunkers used the presence of Menzel on the list as "proof" the documents were forgeries, since Menzel had been a frequent UFO debunker publicly (having written three books on the subject)”
Dark Mission
ch12:70899-71090
Friedman's research into Menzel's papers found he led an elaborate double life
“long-time UFO researcher (and nuclear physicist) Stanton Friedman went painstakingly through Menzel's papers as part of his research for a book on the MJ 12 documents, and discovered that Menzel had led an elaborate double life”
Dark Mission
ch12:71453-71676
Menzel's papers showed links to intelligence projects and top-secret weapons programmes
“Friedman found numerous references to Menzel's participation in a variety of intelligence projects and committees, including some top-secret weapons programs that would have made him an ideal candidate for MJ 12.”
Dark Mission
ch12:71682-71891
Friedman argues for the validity of the MJ-12 documents and organisation
“Friedman also makes a compelling argument for the validity of the MJ 12 documents, and the existence of MJ 12 itself.”
Dark Mission
ch12:71895-72005
Researchers have identified Theodore von Karman as a possible MJ-12 member
“The MJ-12 document researchers have also identified Von Karman as a possible member of MJ-12—based on his name appearing on certain new documents they have been recently unearthed.”
Dark Mission
ch12:79156-79328
Caplan examined typography, printing, watermarks and terminology to assess provenance
“You've looked at the typography, the printing, the format, the watermarks, the terminology used, the corroboration from other diaries.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:25:59.3-00:26:08.0
Caplan finds the documents corroborate unreleased Truman, Forrestal and Eisenhower diaries
“the detail of the documents check out with contemporary diaries, which were not released at the time. The meetings that are referred to in the documents are reflected in the diaries of not just the president, but Forrestal, Eisenhower.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:20:15.5-00:20:30.3
Caplan examined the AEC head's diaries and found they corroborate the documents
“I've looked at the diaries of the head of the Atomic Energy Commission, and it just does knit together.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:20:32.1-00:20:41.4
Caplan discounts the counterintelligence-operation theory, believing most documents genuine
“I really do discount that because ... the detail checks out, they are such a quantity of these documents, many of which don't have any counterintelligence consequence at all. And I'm pretty sure that most of them, not all of them, but most of them are genuine.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:20:51.1-00:21:11.5
Coulthart notes debunkers claim Angleton fabricated the documents to disinform the Soviets
“the documents were conceived by James Jesus Angleton, the notorious head of counterintelligence for the CIA, who on the account that's given by the debunkers, he supposedly created these documents to disinform the Soviets into the belief that the Americans had recovered alien technology.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:21:18.3-00:21:38.0
Coulthart rejects the Angleton theory given the volume and detail required
“it never washed with me because I can imagine creating, as you say, one document or a couple of documents or a few documents. This is a vast trove of material. And whoever conceived the documents clearly had a knowledge of names, details, events.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:21:39.9-00:22:01.5
One document notes the president was at Blair House because the White House was being rebuilt
“was it Truman or Eisenhower, one of the documents you talk about, the president was actually at Blair House because the White House was being rebuilt. And I thought that was a very important detail”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:22:08.9-00:22:19.2
Caplan considers it extremely unlikely Forrestal did not tell Tizard about MJ-12
“it is extremely unlikely that Forrestal did not tell Sir Henry about Majestic 12, the reason that it had been set up because of the craft that had been found and the biologics that went with it.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:13:58.8-00:14:13.3
Coulthart considers it extremely unlikely Forrestal and Bush did not brief Tizard on MJ-12
“it's unlikely in the extreme that they didn't brief Tizard on the UFOs issue on Majestic.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:23:06.0-00:23:13.8
Caplan believes Forrestal impressed the need for secrecy on Tizard
“it clearly is the case that Forrestal impressed on Tizard that this had to be kept under wraps that they should go away and do their own research and that they should limit the documents that they're producing, possibly only for his own personal use.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:23:56.4-00:24:14.7
Caplan concludes Majestic 12 existed and the documents are genuine
“i conclude that a majestic 12 existed and that the documents are real”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:13:12.8-00:13:17.9
Coulthart considers the files authentic beyond doubt
“I mean, no doubt whatsoever that they are authentic.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:16:28.0-00:16:30.4
Coulthart is not fully convinced some subsequent documents were not planted disinformation
“I'm yet to be convinced fully that there's not ... the possibility that there might have been deliberate disinformation planted in some of the subsequent MJ-12 documents.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:16:31.4-00:16:41.5
Caplan considers it likely the agreement Truman referenced at Blair House relates to MJ-12
“But in the context of the discussion that we're having, it's very likely that it's something to do, I would say, with Majestic 12.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:25:44.6-00:25:52.6
Many classic MJ-12 documents came via Timothy Cooper, a US Marine Corps veteran
“So a lot of the classic MJ-12 documents came via a gentleman called Tim Cooper, Timothy Cooper, who was a US Marine Corps veteran”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:28:35.3-00:28:43.5
Caplan obtained new documents held by Ryan Wood, keeper of the MJ-12 archive
“And you've obtained key new documents that were held by Ryan Wood, who's one of the keepers of the MJ-12 archive.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:28:57.5-00:29:06.8
Caplan met Wood and asked whether Cooper had handed over all the documents to his father
“The two documents that are new came about because when I was in Washington about two years ago, I met with Ryan Wood And I asked him whether he felt that Tim Cooper had handed over all the Majestic documents to his father when his father visited him and obtained the original tranche.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:29:39.8-00:30:05.4
One new document concerns the Blair House meeting, part of an annex to an MJ-12 report
“One of them is the document of the meeting at Blair House on the 14th of July, 1949, which is part of an annex to a Majestic 12 report.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:31:01.1-00:31:13.8
Another part of the annex, paragraphs nine onwards, was already disclosed before the new pages
“Another part of that annex had already been disclosed. That was paragraphs nine, I think onwards. This is paragraphs one to eight, and this page had not been disclosed.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:31:15.4-00:31:26.5
The newly disclosed page discusses Truman wanting to share MJ-12 material with US allies
“And this is the page which talks about Truman wanting to share some of the Majestic material with his allies.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:31:28.1-00:31:39.4
The documents were not handed over previously, largely down to what Cooper was prepared to give
“It just wasn't handed over. I think it was very much a question of getting what Tim Cooper was prepared to give them. And some of the material was left behind.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:44:15.6-00:44:26.4
Caplan found one or two forged typescript documents among the material
“I have found one or two documents which are not original, don't purport to be original documents of the time, but which are typescript documents which were disclosed amongst the Majestic 12 material, which I do believe were forged.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:27:19.5-00:27:37.8
A forged document, 'Truman and Congress', purports to show Truman testifying to Congress in 1963/64
“And one of them is a document, I think, involving or headed Truman and Congress. And it purports to be an account of Truman being called to give evidence at Congress in 1963 or 1964, where he's asked about MJ-12 and he is embarrassed and gives various answers.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:27:38.9-00:28:07.4
The quantity and detail of the documents, much now confirmable, argues against forgery
“And it's the quantity of these documents, the detail in the documents, which can now be confirmed in many respects,”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:43:06.0-00:43:13.9
Some documents are routine letters bearing an MJ-12 stamp with no counterintelligence benefit
“And also there are documents amongst the MJ-12 material which really don't have any particular counterintelligence benefit which are routine exchanges of letters between people with an MJ-12 stamp on and there's no purpose in creating that kind of material and you'd had to have had an army of people really who would have had to have had a vast amount of sources to put this material together the detail is impressive”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:43:15.2-00:43:51.0
Caplan considers the documents confirmed by access to now-available public records
“And as I say, it's confirmed by access to a range of public documents that are now available.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:43:53.8-00:43:59.7
Photographs marked 'MJ-12' on the back depict scientists, many identified as Paperclip scientists
“also amongst those photographs were photographs of a number of people with MJ-12 on the back and these were um scientists many of them paperclip scientists who um we know from other sources um have worked for MJ-12”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:45:36.7-00:45:52.8
Von Neumann, Szilard and Teller are among the scientists identified in the photographs
“And those are people like John von Neumann, zillard edward teller”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:45:54.6-00:46:02.7
Walker told other ufologists that von Neumann was working at Majestic 12
“from other sources we know um that um for example uh dr eric walker has spoken to other uh ufologists many years ago william steinman to confirm um that van neumann actually was working at MJ-12”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:46:05.1-00:46:20.6
Walker confirmed he himself had worked at Majestic 12
“and eric walker confirms he had worked at MJ-12”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:46:21.5-00:46:24.6
Others working on MJ-12 projects have confirmed von Neumann's involvement
“We know also that others have confirmed who were working at that time on these projects that van Neumann was working on MJ-12 projects.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:46:26.4-00:46:38.4
James Lay appears as consulted over Roswell and supporting MJ-12's establishment
“And James Lay actually appears in an earlier Majestic 12 document as having been one of the people that was consulted over Roswell and who supported the establishment of MJ-12 as a separate intelligence unit.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:39:55.2-00:40:09.2
Wilson and Miller talked privately for two hours about UFOs, MJ-12 and Roswell after the 1997 briefing
“After group broke up, Miller/Wilson talked (privately) 2 hours on UFOs, MJ-12, Roswell, crashed UFOs/alien bodies, etc.”
EWD Notes - Eric Davis Meeting with Adm. Wilson
char:1412-1527
Wilson told a programme manager he had read their record and asked about MJ-12
“TW: I told I read their program record in the OUSDAT special program records group and wanted to know about their crashed UFO program, what their role in that was, what they had, etc. Also asked if they heard of MJ-12 or some such organization code relating to crashed/recovered UFO craft.”
EWD Notes - Eric Davis Meeting with Adm. Wilson
char:15027-15306
Wilson called Miller in June 1997 and confirmed a Majestic 12-like organisation exists
“Confirmed he called Miller ca. late June '97 and told that he/Miller was right - there is such an organization in existence.”
EWD Notes - Eric Davis Meeting with Adm. Wilson
char:1738-1852
Wilson described a Shannon-Miller discussion touching on a Boston Globe story and an MJ-12-like cabal
“Re: Boston Globe Story - L. Kean. Yep, UFO topic - crashed/retrieved UFO craft/bodies, etc. MJ-12 like UFO organization (or cabal).”
EWD Notes - Eric Davis Meeting with Adm. Wilson
char:1063-1183
Coulthart's understanding: senior public servants are briefed on MJ-12 matters, rarely elected politicians
“it suggests that there are and this is certainly my understanding that there are senior public servants who are briefed in by the americans but that it's very rare for politicians to be briefed in”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:34:08.7-00:34:21.4
The Lancer document was among those leaked as part of the MJ-12 trove
“this is one of the documents which was leaked amongst the Majestic 12 Trove”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
00:59:46.0-00:59:55.8
The officer who disclosed the Lancer document said it tied the CIA to Kennedy's assassination
“in sending the document and disclosing it as part of the Majestic 12 Trove, he said look this is the last piece of evidence that will tie the CIA into Kennedy's assassination”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
01:00:53.6-01:01:05.9
Coulthart describes the Lancer document as an overt intention by MJ-12 members to murder Kennedy
“It is chilling because it's an overt expression of intention by members of the alleged MJ-12 to murder the President of the United States.”
Watergate, the JFK assassination and a UFO secret at the center of it all | Reality Check
01:01:55.4-01:02:09.5