Skip to content

The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks

An interview in which Benjamin Simon discusses his psychiatric treatment of Betty Hill and Barney Hill, the hypnosis sessions that recovered their accounts of a missing two-hour period, and his conclusion that Betty Hill’s abduction narrative derived from earlier nightmares rather than a visitation from outer space.

Video · 33 min

This source is an interview presenting Benjamin Simon’s account of his involvement with Betty Hill and [Barney Hill]. According to the source record, Simon was a psychiatrist based in the Boston area and was called upon to interview, psychoanalyse and hypnotise the couple.12 He said that he kept an appointment with Barney near Christmas in late 1963, after Barney had received treatment for about a year from a psychiatrist in New Hampshire for marked anxiety; Simon also reported symptoms of high blood pressure.345 Simon traced the case to a six-page report by the National Investigations Committee on Aerial Phenomena (NICAP), describing the couple’s sighting of an Unidentified Flying Object (UFO). He said the NICAP investigator believed their story and that the missing two hours first emerged during Barney’s earlier treatment.678 He further associated Barney’s anxiety with the period immediately after the sighting, while describing Betty as having nightmarish dreams lasting a week or more.910

Simon described hypnosis as an attempt to explore an apparently amnesic interval of approximately two hours on the journey home from Canada, Quebec, Montreal.11 He said the sessions began at Montreal and were conducted separately, beginning with Barney, with each participant directed to relive and act out the journey.12 According to Simon, the two accounts under hypnosis matched one another and the NICAP report, while also revealing significant differences after the sighting.13 He observed anxiety in Barney’s account about being a black man in a white culture.14 He said Betty’s account was more vivid and detailed than Barney’s, and included a landed UFO, beeping sounds, a stalled car, silver-like spots and an alleged boarding and examination.151617

The source matters because Simon presents the case as both a clinical record and a problem of interpretation. He said a hypnotised person may describe the truth as they see it without that necessarily being objective reality.18 Betty reportedly had written down her dreams in 1961, and Simon said that record matched her hypnotic account except for its references to both a ramp and steps.1920 He concluded that the abduction narrative derived from those nightmares and did not require a visitation from outer space.21 Consistently with that position, Simon defined a UFO as an unidentified object without an inherent extraterrestrial implication, referred to Donald Menzel’s discussion of weather balloons and to ball lightning, and proposed an American Airlines plane and a lighted sign near Hartford as stimuli for the sighting.222324

References (25)
  1. Benjamin Simon is described as a psychiatrist based in the Boston area.
    “He's a psychiatrist in the Boston area”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:00:12.3-00:00:13.8
  2. Simon was called on to interview, psychoanalyse and hypnotise Betty and Barney Hill.
    “he was called on to interview, psychoanalyze, and hypnotize Betty Hill and Barney Hill”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:00:14.4-00:00:20.6
  3. Simon kept an appointment with Barney Hill near Christmas in late 1963.
    “Well, it was in late '63, quite near Christmas time. And I kept an appointment which my secretary had made with a Mr. Barney Hill.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:01:24.4-00:01:34.2
  4. Barney Hill had received treatment for about a year from a New Hampshire psychiatrist for marked anxiety before his referral.
    “He gave me the several stories that he had been under treatment for about a year with a New Hampshire psychiatrist. for marked anxiety, had also symptoms of high blood pressure. And over the year, he hadn't gotten very far and was ultimately recommended to me by his psychiatrist.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:01:44.0-00:02:07.4
  5. Barney Hill also had symptoms of high blood pressure.
    “had also symptoms of high blood pressure”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:01:55.7-00:01:58.1
  6. Simon traced the case to a six-page NICAP report describing the Hills’ UFO sighting.
    “they began almost at the beginning with a six-page report from NICAP...this was the story of their seeing an unidentified flying object, which was investigated by a NICAP investigator who made this report”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:02:15.3-00:02:36.0
  7. The NICAP investigator who wrote the report believed the Hills’ story.
    “He had intimated that they were put on his people and that he believed the story.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:02:40.6-00:02:46.4
  8. The missing two hours first came to light during Barney Hill’s treatment by his New Hampshire psychiatrist.
    “That story had first come to light doing the treatment by his New Hampshire psychiatrist.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:02:47.7-00:02:55.1
  9. Barney Hill’s anxiety symptoms began just after the reported sighting.
    “Barney's symptoms had begun just after they had this supposed sighting.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:03:25.1-00:03:30.6
  10. Betty Hill experienced nightmarish dreams for a week or more after the sighting.
    “Betty had responded by a series of dreams extending over a week or more about nightmarish quality.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:03:31.9-00:03:38.4
  11. Simon used hypnosis to explore an apparently amnesic period covering approximately two hours of the journey home from Canada.
    “to take both of the treatment and to use hypnosis to penetrate what appeared to be an amnesic period with very vague background. The only feeling they had was that coming back on a trip from Canada, they got home about two hours later than they should have, and they had no idea what had happened”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:03:47.5-00:04:13.5
  12. The sessions began at Montreal, Quebec, Canada, and involved hypnotising the Hills separately, beginning with Barney.
    “I took them back to a starting point of Montreal. They had been to Niagara Falls and were coming home. And Montreal, you might say, was at the top of the journey...coming down to New Hampshire.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:05:09.2-00:05:52.7
  13. Under hypnosis, both Hills gave the same account, which Simon said matched the NICAP investigator’s report.
    “Barney and Betty gave the same story. And that story was precisely like the story that had been written up by the NICAP investigators. There were no significant difference, in fact, actually no differences between the three.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:06:19.7-00:06:36.6
  14. Simon observed that Barney Hill’s account revealed anxiety about being a black man in a white culture.
    “What marked the trip, particularly from Barney's point of view, up to the time of the sighting, was a revelation, coming mostly from his unconscious, of the marked anxiety he had in being a black man in a white culture.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:06:54.2-00:07:11.5
  15. Simon said the Hills’ accounts matched up to the sighting, after which Betty’s was more vivid and detailed than Barney’s.
    “up to the point of the sighting and those experiences, the two stories were exactly alike...Betty's experiences were far more vivid, fog there, and much more material there than Barney, who simply felt himself as being supportive with his eyes closed...Nothing of Betty's story, but nothing was in Barney's story.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:15:02.7-00:15:24.5
  16. Betty Hill’s account described the UFO landing, making beeping sounds, stalling the car and leaving silver-like spots on it.
    “Betty's story went on beyond that in telling the story of having been, that the UFO had landed, had made beeping sounds and had stalled their motor and various things of that sort and had caused silver-like spots to appear on their car.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:11:05.8-00:11:25.6
  17. Her account also described the Hills being taken aboard and separated for examination.
    “She went on with a fantastic story of having been taken aboard. She described Barney as, with his eyes closed, as sort of suspended between two men who were half dragging him along to the same vehicle, and she had her eyes open and did not have to be dragged, and she was taken along by what appeared to be the leader of the group”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:11:49.0-00:12:26.9
  18. Simon distinguished between a hypnotised person’s truth as they see it and objective reality.
    “there's one thing that is important that a hypnotized person tells the truth. But you've got to remember...that he tells it as he sees it, as it sees the truth to him, which may not be the true reality. That doesn't mean he has lied or maligned.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:18:42.5-00:18:58.4
  19. Betty Hill said she had written down her dreams in 1961.
    “She said she had written them down at the time they occurred. That means way back in '61. But couldn't find... I asked her to bring it in. She said she couldn't find the dreams.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:19:16.7-00:19:28.1
  20. The written dream record matched her hypnotic account except that it described both a ramp and steps.
    “they were exactly alike with one difference. That in the dreams, she went up both a ramp and steps.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:20:36.8-00:20:42.4
  21. Simon concluded that Betty Hill’s abduction story derived from her nightmares and did not require a visitation from outer space.
    “that gave me an answer at that point, that this fantastic story was her dreams, and therefore we could fit that very well with reality...I was satisfied. I didn't have to look any further for an explanation. I wouldn't have to accept under our present conditions the existence of this just amount of space”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:20:56.8-00:21:25.3
  22. Simon defined a UFO as an unidentified flying object without implying extraterrestrial visitation.
    “I must define UFO as I see it. It means an unidentified flying object, and that's all it means. It can be Mendel's balloons, weather balloons, misinterpreted, or anything else. It does not by its definition, imply visitation from out of space”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:14:12.3-00:14:28.4
  23. Donald Menzel was said to have described weather balloons and other aerial phenomena that can resemble UFOs.
    “Menzel of Harvard has described many aerial phenomena, weather balloons and thoughts that under certain weather conditions can look like UFOs.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:29:40.8-00:29:51.4
  24. A Washington scientist proposed ball lightning as a possible stimulus for UFO sightings.
    “A class in Washington has cited, has mentioned his theory of ball lightning as a base stimulus.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:29:52.7-00:30:00.6
  25. Simon attributed the sighting to an American Airlines plane and a brilliantly lighted sign near Hartford, Connecticut, reflected through mist.
    “the two stimuli, without giving the story, turned out to be the American Airlines plane, and the one which I saw long before I ever knew the Hill's and one subsequently unseen by me, and another is a guy that turned out to be a brilliantly lighted sign outside of Hartford, which was reflected through misty sky.”
    The Hypnotist Who Unlocked Betty & Barney Hill’s Alien Memories | Dr. Benjamin Simon Speaks 00:30:03.7-00:30:24.5

Language

30 languages covering 80% of the world's literate population

English English English (US) English (US) Spanish Español Portuguese Português Indonesian Bahasa Indonesia French Français Swahili Kiswahili Vietnamese Tiếng Việt Turkish Türkçe German Deutsch Italian Italiano Uzbek Oʻzbekcha Polish Polski Tagalog Tagalog
Mandarin 中文 Traditional Chinese 繁體中文 Japanese 日本語 Korean 한국어
Arabic العربية Urdu اردو Persian فارسی
Russian Русский Ukrainian Українська
Hindi हिन्दी Bengali বাংলা Thai ไทย Burmese မြန်မာ Telugu తెలుగు Marathi मराठी Tamil தமிழ்